Relationships I want to preface this update with an expression of gratitude to everyone who gave me advice. I received direct messages from a startling number of men who have dated or married a woman with similar issues as Claire.
One of these messages led to a conversation, and something the commenter said really resonated with me: he told me that in his case, his wife doesn’t really understand the concept of guilt.
She doesn’t understand phrases like “You made me feel sad when you said X,” or “The way you treated me hurt my feelings.” He eventually came to an epiphany that while trying to make her understand guilt and feelings was a waste of time, she actually had a good grasp on shame, and he was able to leverage that against her.
My next run-in with Claire happened when we went out to dinner two weeks after Kevin’s play. We went to Cheesecake Factory.
The problem that night began when I ordered an appetizer first, which caused Claire to immediately call me a “fucking selfish idiot.” I was apparently supposed to go Kevin’s order -> Claire’s order -> appetizer -> my order.
Now, before, I would usually just fix my “mistake” to disarm Claire.
But this time, I calmly responded, “You’re embarrassing yourself and making everyone uncomfortable.” Claire began showing her typical pre-tantrum signs (face going red, shaking), and while she let me finish ordering, after the waitress walked away she whisper-shouted about how terrible of a human being I was.
I responded in a neutral but audible voice, “The people at the tables around us are starting to stare. You look unhinged. Do we need to take our order to go or are you going to behave?”
as predicted, Claire decided to double down and cause a scene.
I flagged the waitress down and said that we would be taking our order to go. Now, at that point, Claire REFUSED to move from the booth. So I simply gathered Kevin, and then walked out on her, picking our food up from the takeout counter.
Long story made short, Kevin and I ate in the car overlooking a canyon, watched some movies, and went home. Claire came home later, announced she was leaving because I "abandoned her," and I eagerly helped her pack.
Claire is staying at her parents' house, where Kevin has visited her a few times. We only communicate through texts now (I refuse to answer her calls), but she has admitted that being with me stresses her out so much that she acts like she wouldn't normally. I know. I know.
But I'll take it. We're going to get divorced and co-parent Kevin. I wish Claire well, but the woman is a disaster, through and through.